What Do the Past Winners of America’s Next Top Model Look Like Today?

McKey Sullivan won Cycle 11 in 2008 with a look that felt almost editorial from day one. Tall, angular, and slightly mysterious, she thrived in high-fashion shoots and rarely seemed rattled. While other contestants brought louder personalities, McKey let her photos speak — and they consistently did.

By the Amsterdam finale, she looked like the most model-ready of the group. The judges leaned into her versatility and quiet intensity, handing her a win that felt aligned with the show’s more fashion-forward ambitions that cycle.